Unanswered Questions

The thing about researching is how easily the objective can be derailed. Well, at least in my genealogy research. How I get distracted I can't say specifically, but yesterday I found myself on my son's branch of his family after seeing an intriguing news article on Newspapers.com.  The last several years of his great grandfather's life have some unanswered questions.

According to a "Special to the Inquirer" news article in the Philadelphia Inquirer, Fred Wegelin disappeared from his New Jersey home in November 1914 without mentioning anything to his wife, Minnie. After several days of absence, Minnie reported Fred missing.

I knew the Wegelin family line had ties to Birmingham Alabama, so my research went in that direction on a hunch. Narrowing down the search for Fred to Alabama newspapers and a time period starting from 1914, I hoped to find an article with the answer to this mystery. What I found was a vague item reporting his death in December 1917.

My next step was to find the death certificate. This record type shows the cause of death among other vital dates and information. Unfortunately, Alabama has not digitized their death records for online research. A copy can be obtained from the state for a fee or looked up in person at the repository where it's archived. The index information (the county of record, book volume number and page number) for Fred's record was found online and is a great help requesting the death certificate in person. The death being indexed also confirms the date and event is true, in light of the vague blurb in the newspaper.

Fred's will and his wife Minnie's petition of probate (to have the will authenticated) were found online.  This online transcript is of the court proceeding and Fred's will, not the original will document. According to the transcribed details of the will, it was written by Fred and witnessed by two gentlemen on March 3, 1917 in Birmingham Alabama, nine months prior to his death.

It's unclear to me if Minnie had to travel to Birmingham to petition in person or have a lawyer handle the process. A sentence in the petition transcript suggests to me she had the will in her possession and presented it to the Alabama authorities, but the transcription does not state she signed any document or was present at court as far as I can tell. The two witnesses signed a short statement confirming the will was the one they signed as witnesses in March 1917 and the judge officially sealed it.

The unanswered questions remaining are: Why did Fred leave his family without notice in 1914? Did Minnie have the original will? If so, did Fred return to New Jersey to give her the will or did he mail it to her? Where was he between November 1914 and the writing of the will in Alabama? Was Fred in some trouble during this period making him fear for his life and write a will at the age of 37? Was his death an accident (and what kind of accident) or was he killed?

"Update" ... After rereading the transcription of Minnie's petition closely, I find that she signed the petition in front of a Notary Public in Atlantic County New Jersey, close to her Egg Harbor City home. The NP mailed the sworn statement to Jefferson County Alabama to start probate of her deceased husband's will.